Thursday 31 July 2008

The Decline of Hinduism amongst Hindus

The Decline of Hinduism amongst Hindus

Many Hindus believe that we now enter a period in the age of this world that is called ‘Kali Yuga’ or the ‘age of vice’ characterised by the decline of morality amongst men, the inability to separate right from wrong, corruption between relationships between the strata of the society, between friends and family; just to mention a few. Even a sceptic or a non-Hindu would be pressed hard to disagree given the self destructive nature that men have demonstrated in recent times.

For a long time, I struggled to understand this particular concept which I felt somewhat seemed like it represented the hypocrisy of Hinduism. I failed to understand how Hinduism, a religion that is meant to save and guide mankind predicts its own inability to save man from sin. That surely a religion so pure and true, would be able to save its believers from being condemned into a realm of impurities and sin, and through its teachings help them achieve self realisation.

But upon embarking my slow and steady religious journey, I have stumbled across a series of remarkable observations and realisations, and maybe even possibly am beginning to comprehend some of the very core concepts of Hinduism (and other religions). Stark obvious to many, but a fundamental concept that had previously eluded me; for I have learnt, that God and religion may never save every soul that exists, but instead, every soul has the opportunity through God and religion to save itself from self damnation; that bad and evil is not the failure of God or religion, but purely the absence of it.

I risk incurring the wrath of many sceptics and atheist, who will simply point towards the numerous wars, crimes, pain and suffering that has been inflicted by one man onto another in the name of God and religion. However, I can only assure you, that these very men, who used God’s name and religion in vain, have never really understood either, and were purely driven by themselves or others like themselves, who were victims of the failings and misconceptions of religious teachings. It is only lately that I have realised that although I have been born a Hindu, and practised Hinduism all my life, it is only over the last few years I have began to live as a Hindu. This draws me towards the compulsion to explain the decline of Hinduism or more accurately, the lost principles of Hinduism amongst Hindus.

I recently attended a temple function, during which a priest delivered a sermon, teaching the temple crowd about some of the aspects of Hinduism. Thirty minutes into his sermon, I left, slightly disappointed by the narrow teachings of the priest. Alternating between Hindi and English, the priest explained parts of text quoted from the Ramayana, teaching the temple crowd about the value devotion as opposed to temptation, warning against seduced by superficial beauty and encouraged the crowd to learn and acquire knowledge; advising his audience to live proudly and true to the values of an Indian, and rejecting the corruption of the west. Everything the priest delivered, was direct, relevant and most importantly gave good guidance and direction to all those who listened. But his single shortcoming was his failure to understand, that the concepts of Hinduism extended beyond the cultural and traditionalistic limitations of the Indian subcontinent. Simply put, the priest implied that one ought to live the life of a traditional Indian. In fact, implicating western civilisations as the reason of corruption amongst Hindus may even be perceived as a denial of their own inability to withstand the test of globalisation.

Hinduism was born by the side of the Ganges River in the ancient Indian civilisation, and naturally many Indians would have lived and practiced Hinduism to an extent, the terms ‘Indian lifestyle’ or ‘Indian culture’ could perhaps possibly be used interchangeably or perhaps synonymously as Hinduism, at that point in time in history. But the evolution of society, culture and tradition has changed all this. The traditional Indian culture that was largely shaped and influenced by Hinduism may no longer reflect the true teachings of the very religion that shaped it.

Therefore, although the Indian culture and the teachings of Hinduism may be have interchangeably influenced each other to the point the teachings of Hinduism is immersed in the traditional Indian culture and vice versa, a Hindu must learn to demarcate these two areas to be able to appreciate Hinduism in its purest form. This however, may appear to be a task equivalent to seeking the ‘Holy Grail’, purely because unlike other religions, Hinduism, does not draw its religious authority from a single source, but instead relies heavily on the numerous ancient Sanskrit texts that exists in the form of the Vedas, the Upanishads, the Puranas, the ‘smritis’, and even from the epic poems Ramayana and the Mahabharata of which the Bhagavad Gita is a part of. And it is of utmost importance that these texts and scriptures are interpreted in the context in which they were written, hence heavily influenced by the Indian culture and traditions.

Therefore, I understand, and perhaps am able to forgive Hindus who are under the misconception that the traditional Indian culture and lifestyle epitomises the principles of Hinduism. What irks me however is the failure of Hindus to evolve and adapt these very principles to the modern day and ultimately the failure to develop and live by the principles of Hinduism.

As simple example is as follows:
“...Hindus may pray to God in the various forms He has chose to reveal Himself to man. Whether it be through the reincarnation of Lord Vishnu in the form of Rama, or through Lord Krishna the charioteer to Prince Arjuna in the battle of Kurushetra.

…As a Hindu, a child would often be taught to clasp their hands together, in front of these idols, and pray; with prayer being in the form of offering thanks to God for all He has provided us with, apologies for our numerous shortcomings or sins we have committed and finally submitting to God our needs, so He would bless us in all our future endeavours and help us achieve them. We were taught to prepare myself for the rituals, on how to participate and conduct ourselves during these rituals. But very often that was the extent of how much an average Hindu child is taught about the religion…”

Temples, parents or religious classes that teach Hinduism is a rarity, and may be limited to selected religious texts or pure mythology. Hence, when the priests would chant prayers and mantras in Sanskrit and calmly conduct each step of the meticulous and complex rituals, very little of the procedure itself is understood by the Hindus participating in the ritual, but eventually simply learn to accept it. Enduring ignorance in silence, the core teachings are simply lost and masked by our ignorant diligence in performing prayer without understanding it, hence rendering prayer, worship and devotion meaningless. Worse still, is the blatant ignorance that has beset many Hindus, who are dominated by prayer, worship and rituals, forgetting or in some cases never learning about the facets of Hinduism that deal with complex but important concepts such as dharma, karma and conduct.

Outside prayer, worship and devotion, ‘Hinduism’ as it is practiced now fails to prepare Hindus to face the realities of life, due to the neglect of the principles of Hinduism. Adopting a broad generalised view, merely comparing Hinduism to other religions such as Islam and Christianity, it appears to me that Muslims and Christians generally understand and grasp the principles of their respective religions better than Hindus with Hinduism. This in turn allows Muslims and Christians to be better prepared to face the realities in life, such as dealing with significant stressful life events, such as birth and separation, dealing with fortune and misfortune, conduct of relationships between family, relatives and friends, roles and responsibilities and ultimately death.

Hindus, generally less knowledgeable in Hinduism, are often left confused and lost in the face of reality. Thus Hinduism becomes superficial in meaning, as the valuable teachings of the ancient Sanskrit teachings such as the Vedas and the Bhagavad Gita are gradually being replaced by ritualism and symbolism. Ask any Hindu about his or her purpose in life, and do not be surprised if your question is met with hesitancy or a long winded philosophical answer; clear evidence of the stark lack of knowledge of the religion by its followers.

Religion is meant to guide and lead. It is meant to provide direction, a source to derive strength, faith and hope. Therefore if Hinduism is to serve its purpose as a religion, it needs to be accessible to its believers. It needs to be practical and practicable in this age in time. Instead of clinging on to the ritualism, symbolism, traditionalist mindset that defined Hinduism in the culture of the bygone ages of ancient India, present day Hindus need to understand that globalisation has changed the face of this world.

The culture of ancient India may not necessarily be practicable now, but Hindus must learn that that does not imply Hinduism is impractical. Hinduism should not be confined to India or the Indian lifestyle. It purely means that Hindus must reach back into the depths of the religion to acquire knowledge and learn the principles of Hinduism, to understand how Hinduism can be practised in the present and the future. Although the outlook of future Hindu practise may appear different from ancient practise, the core must remain the same. This evolutionary process which dictates change in practise of Hinduism may be criticised by many traditionalist who may claim that changes in traditional Hindu practice equates to deviance. But I view this evolutionary change as not deviance, but instead an expansion of our knowledge and understanding of the religion and hence brings us closer to God.

My belief is simple, “A man who calls himself a Muslim, who attends the mosque and prays like a Muslim, and acts like a Muslim but who himself does not understand nor live by the principles of Islam is not truly a Muslim. A man who calls himself a Catholic, who attends the church and prays like a Catholic, and acts like a Catholic but who himself does not understand nor live by the principles of Christianity is not a truly a Catholic. Likewise, a man who calls himself a Hindu, who attends the temple and prays like a Hindu, and acts like a Hindu, but who himself does not understand nor live by the principles of Hinduism is not a truly a Hindu.”

I do not pretend to be the epitome of knowledge with regards to Hinduism, nor am I a learned scholar in the religion. Instead, I am a purist, who by chance stumbled across the principles of Hinduism and am currently in pursuit of the knowledge that has gradually been dissipating away from Hindus. From what I have learnt, I believe that the way forward to reverse the decline in the Hindu religion is to pluck the principles of Hinduism from its traditional and cultural landscape, to learn it in its purest form, to subsequently allow it to be re-taught correctly to present day Hindus who wish live by the principles of Hinduism. Perhaps then, even Hindus will understand Hinduism better.

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

Glad you started writing - really enjoyed this piece.

I think the point you made about many Hindus not understanding their religion is very true. Using our personal experiences or rather my personal experiences, I can say that our exposure to religion has not been thorough. As a person who likes to question, I find myself getting distant from being a Hindu - as I always question the significance of doing something(rituals in particular). If I do not find a satisfactory explanation, I do not see why I should do it, except maybe it calms me down and this might be psychological as well.

The problem is as you mentioned, there are no proper avenue where you can ask questions and be thought the 'right answer' or appropriate interpretation. I would like Hindus to have sessions like Bible studies, where people meet and discuss a verse of the Bible. It not only opens up our mind but also allows us to think and except/see others' views as well(one sentence can always be interpreted differently by different people).

So, you should carry on this journey about discovering the religion, it's purpose and how we all can contribute to society making people more knowledgeable about Hinduism. I might join in the journey if I can get myself to start reading all these texts.

Anonymous said...

Many Hindus don't understand hinduism due to it's complexity. It is a complex religion, it evolves with time. It is easier to accept and perform rituals rather than understand the complex symbolism behind. Why do we offer flowers in Hindu temples...because it is a symbol of sweetness, of goodness..We emit good vibrations to the divine power. Why sit crossed-legged when praying..because the position helps us attain a higher level of conciousness within ourselves. Why pray facing the east...because it is the source of incoming energy where the sun rises. These are all the very principles of Hinduism. But hinduism today has taken a rigid turn where nobody questions anything, which is why superstitions have become easier to accept.

Anonymous said...

It is not that nobody questions anything, but people do not have time to explore and those how know these are not easy to come by or met. So, who do we direct the questions to? I disagree with annonymous' comment on 'superstitions have become easier to accept' - less people accept it now than before. There is a certain sense in it in the instance where people accept it for society's reason or just to keep their elders in the family happy(although they do not entirely agree/understand them).

Anonymous said...

I am one who questions a lot as well. How is it that rituals can help...i've dug into it a lot and these are just the few answers i have. Coconuts resemble our human head. Breaking it signifies breaking our human ego. Fasting (and this is something i've tried myself) helps you resist temptations because you reach a higher level of conciousness. I always wondered how is it that fasting can make a difference to my future...fasting doesn't make a difference to your future directly. It helps YOU make a difference to your OWN future. And it is downright true, speaking from firsthand experience. How is it that mantras help...because chanting it emits certain vibrations which travels into the right channels in our mind. (this is in simple english...the underlying theory is way deeper than that). And how do we know vibrations exist...the very fact that mobile phones exist says it all..from vibrations to wavelengths to communication. And how true are these theories...I wish I had an answer. We may think, how far can these symbolic rituals help us...i mean the impact of symbolic rituals are far smaller than the impact of our troubles, so how can they help? You won't know until you try it. It works, and it works miracles, you just have to trust that there is a divine power. And we should go on questioning, because for every 100 questions, we might at least find 2% answers which brings us 2% closer to the religion.

(P.S. A helpful source may be subscribing to Hinduism Today. I think it's free too ;-) )

Anonymous said...

I am not a Hindu so I can't comment much. I read that some Hindus of lower caste choose to convert to Buddhism because Hinduism has caused them suffering. They yearn for equility.

Dr Viknesh Jayapalen said...

Thank you for your comments:

Soha, anonymous: I believe that there is a place for rituals. Perhaps its the vibrations they emit, or perhaps it may even induce change by positive psychological changes. I don't think any of us have the answer to that. But i still believe they are necessary. However scriptures like the Upanishads and some of the Vedas help explain ritualism better. I only think these rituals become meaningless if its purely symbolic in nature.

Relax: I wrote a lengthy piece on caste in Hinduism. It is somewhere amidst my unarchived site. Nevertheless allow me to clarify. The verse that has been quoted as the origin of the caste system from the Rig Veda has often been misintepreted. The translation works too have wrongly translated words like 'varna' and 'jati' to the Latin derivative word 'caste'.

I won't be ignorant and deny that many Hindus do practice caste. But i can assure you that Hinduism does not advocate caste. The caste system is living evidence of the corruption and misinformation of the religion. It is these sort of deviant and traditional practise that have persisted under the guise of Hinduism that I seek to abolish by reverting back to the original principles of the religion.

For a better understanding of the caste system, I invite you to read my following entry. I warn you, its a lengthy read.

http://msia-indians.blogspot.com/2007/04/caste-in-hinduism-300-year-old-myth.html

Anonymous said...

Thanks for your clarification. I have read the whole thing. It is scary to know that skin colour racism is involved, which reminds me of modern day USA. The rank systems looks like Theocracy to me. In modern society, western nations preach the seperation of religion and politics.

Too bad the religion is corrupted and many people have to suffer a lot.